12 Best Pizza Places In St. Augustine

Our 12-stop tour of pizza greatness in St. Augustine

© 2016 St. Augustine Buzz Media

There are no shortage of great pizza places in St. Augustine, but if your in desperate need of a slice, this list may help you find the best pizza to curb your appetite. Why only 12? Because 10 wasn’t enough and any more than 12 and we would need to purchase larger pants, haha.

1. Pizza time of st augustine

If your looking for Authentic Brooklyn style pizza in the heart of historic St. Augustine, you probably should hit Pizza Time on St. George St.

Ranked #2 pizza place in the US by tripadvisor and with 1,302 positive reviews, how can you go wrong?

pizza time

Location: 124 Saint George St, Saint Augustine, FL 32084-3610

2. Pizzalleys

With fresh ingredients imported from Italy by the owners, this is as close to authentic Italian as you can get without the long flight and security checks.


Location: 117 St George St, Saint Augustine, FL 32084

3. Borrillo’s pizza & subs

Authentic fold & eat New York style brick oven pizza! If your not folding and eating, your doing it wrong. Great prices and huge slices.


Location: 88 San Marco Ave, Saint Augustine, FL 32084-3258

4. Al’s Pizza

Great pizza and great atmosphere for kids. Seating available on the balcony overlooking historic downtown.

als pizza

Location: 1 Saint George Street, Saint Augustine, FL 32084

5. 180 Vilano Grill & Pizza

Nothing fancy here, just great pizza and a great price. Located in Vilano Beach its worth the short trek over Vilano Bridge to take a taste.

180 vilano grill

Location: 180 Vilano Road, Saint Augustine, FL 32084

6. Verrazano Pizza & Pasta Restaurant

One of our favorite beach side pizza places. A homey New York feel where the owner normally greets you at the door. How can you beat that?


Location: 1057 A1a Beach Blvd, Saint Augustine, FL 32080-6732

7. Carmelos Marketplace

Don’t let the location fool you, a favorite of many locals this place fills up fast. Our favorite here is the calzone. With large portions and a friendly staff, this is a must on your own pizza tour of St. Augustine.

Carmelos Pizza

Location: 146 King Street, Connected to Gas Station

8. Antonios New York Style Pizza

Right next to the St. Augustine Beach Pier you’ll find Antonio’s. A great place to drop-in after a day at the beach. Pizza, subs, and calzones at reasonable prices.


Location: 378 A1A Beach Boulevard, Saint Augustine, FL 32080

9. Mellow Mushroom

A fun place with a great atmosphere. Full bar for the adults, and a great kids menu. If you like beer they have over 40 different brands. Great lunch specials as well.

Mellow mushroom

Location: 410 Anastasia Blvd, Saint Augustine, FL

10. De Leon Pizza

This is our go-to movie night with the family pizza. Located right next door to Epic Theatres, we usually catch a movie and then stop in for a pizza. Huge pizzas and awesome wings. Try the antipasto salad, not too shabby either.

de Leon pizza

Location: 84 Theatre Drive, Saint Augustine, FL 32084

11. Romano’s

With huge portions and quick service right on the beach, you can’t go wrong with Romano’s. We had the white cheese pizza and some eggplant parmesan, it rocked. The price was affordable and they deliver.

Romano's Pizza

Location: 4255 A1A, Saint Augustine, FL 32080

12. Tony’s Pizza

This crescent beach pizza place is our favorite “hole in the wall” stop. Tony’s has been around for years and many returning visitors continue to frequent this restaurant. Try the vegetarian thin crust for a healthy treat. Spaghetti and meatballs are pretty awesome as well.

Tonys pizza

Location: 6975 A1a S # 2, Saint Augustine, FL 32080

Did we miss something? Don’t agree? Post comments below…